You are my doomsday, my only doomsday, please don’t take my doomsday away
Friday, July 30, 2004
I’m not suprised Oneideaperday has stirred up a bit of a fuss with his remarks questioning the assumed fact of global warming.
People love to believe in a doomsday scenario. The supposed gravity of the situation acts like a steroid on the ego; with the future of the planet* at stake, we can all be footsoldiers in the Final Battle. Every choice we make as consumers becomes a matter of life and death - and not just our lives and our deaths, but lives and deaths even unto the hundredth generation of ickle kiddies. So every overpriced organic spud we peel becomes a deposit in our karmic piggy-bank. We slag off Exxon, we sometimes slag off BP, too - it gives us a sense of enormous (oil) well-being!
[Note - not so long ago, when green was just a colour like any other, people had a different juju for their guilt. Although even more loony, this was easier-assuaged, with a groat on the collection plate once a week generally doing the trick.]
Whether it’s right or not, we want to believe in global warming / global terror / original sin, because then we can tick off our checklist (carpool / bunker / bible) and feel OK when we go to bed each night. What’s more, we get to join a club, and everyone likes being in a club, even (especially) those of us whom no club will have. In short, doomsday makes people happy.
It’s understandable, then, that suggesting to people that everything might be OK after all, that their conscientious composting might be all stink and no substance (a lot of hot air), tends to touch a nerve. Having people ignore you, or walk all over you, or do better than you, is tolerable as long as the halo of self-righteousness stays hovering like a holy donut over your head. But when somebody tells you that all your good deeds might just be deeds, with no moral cachet, no free pass to Smugsville attached, it’s hard not to feel inconsequential. Redundant. And like somebody made redundant, you might even feel a bit betrayed -
- suddenly, those worthy recycled Friends of the Earth Christmas cards you’d planned to send this year don’t seem so merry! -
which is why folks start shrieking and stones start flying when you try and take their doomsday away.
*because it’s always the planet isn’t it? Truth is, the planet will be here long after humans, a species dominant on Earth’s landmass for an eyeblink in geological terms, have blown themselves up or drowned or died of bugs or buggered off to Mars. What we really mean is saving ourselves. And not just hom. sap., but our species the way it is now. That we might do what we claim to do best, and adapt to an altered planet, doesn’t seem to be an option. So when we talk about saving “the planet,” we’re being typical arrogant hominids. The planet doesn’t give a toss about us, or anything else. Only we care whether it’s 20 degrees or 50 in the shade. But to admit that makes us feel as small as we are, on any scale other than our own. So we talk in special lingo, where the planet means us, and a delicate ecosystem connotes our C20 / 21 comfy industrial lifestyle.